Bachmann Consulting, LLC logo
← Insights

Third-Party Crime and Premises Liability: The Texas Supreme Court Weighs In Again

2026-10-27

In 2026, the Supreme Court of Texas received briefing in In re Simon Property Group, L.P. (No. 26-0023), an original proceeding connected to litigation over the 2023 shooting at Allen Premium Outlets. Business and insurance groups filed amicus briefs in July 2026 urging the Court to reaffirm that businesses generally owe no duty to protect against unforeseeable third-party crime.

The framework they point to is long-standing: Timberwalk Apartments v. Cain (1998), Trammell Crow Central Texas v. Gutierrez (2008), and UDR Texas Properties v. Petrie (2017). Whatever the Court decides, the case shows how much turns on the evidence of prior crime and on how that evidence is analyzed.

Status of the case may have changed since this article was written; consult the Supreme Court of Texas docket for current information.

Competent crime analysis helps every party here: which incidents occurred, where, when, and how similar they were. That is the foundation of any honest foreseeability opinion.

Discuss your matter

General information only; not legal advice. Bachmann Consulting, LLC provides expert analysis, not legal services.