Bachmann Consulting, LLC logo
← Insights

Why Crime Statistics Alone Do Not Prove Foreseeability in Texas

2026-10-15

Under Timberwalk, foreseeability of criminal conduct is assessed by the proximity, recency, frequency, similarity, and publicity of prior crimes. The Court has said that statistics about large or undefined geographic areas do not, by themselves, make crime foreseeable at a specific location.

In practice, this means that a city-wide crime rate, a national headline, or a single dramatic incident rarely settles the question. What matters is a careful, location-specific reconstruction of incidents, adjusted for reporting practices, time windows, and crime type.

Geospatial and statistical methods let an expert test whether prior incidents were close enough, recent enough, frequent enough, and similar enough to the crime at issue, and just as importantly, when they were not.

Whether you represent an injured party or a property owner, the same discipline applies: define the area, define the period, classify the incidents, and let the data speak.

Discuss your matter

General information only; not legal advice. Bachmann Consulting, LLC provides expert analysis, not legal services.