On June 27, 2025, the Supreme Court of Texas decided Werner Enterprises, Inc. v. Blake, 719 S.W.3d 525 (Tex. 2025), reversing a verdict of roughly $100 million. The Court held that the defendants' conduct was not a legal cause of the plaintiffs' injuries.
The opinion restates a basic rule: proximate cause has two elements, cause in fact and foreseeability. Cause in fact requires more than 'but for' causation; the defendant's conduct must be a substantial factor in bringing about the harm.
For parties in negligence disputes, the decision is a reminder that foreseeability cannot be assumed after the fact. It has to be examined with evidence: what was known, what patterns existed, and what a reasonable party could have anticipated at the time.
This is where a qualified expert adds value. A criminologist or data analyst can separate hindsight from genuine foreseeability, test claims against the actual record, and explain the analysis to a judge or jury in plain terms.
General information only; not legal advice. Bachmann Consulting, LLC provides expert analysis, not legal services.